Date (happened)
- 1905 (probable)phase-2 canonical event (fingerprint references)
- 8 July 1906 (possible)historical-photographs-of-dr-modeste-abdallah-guillaume-abdullah-neville-goddards-teacher.txt — "Williams & Walker Glee Club, The Pittsburgh Post, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, July 8, 1906, page 36"
- c. July 1905 (probable)neville-goddards-abdullah-the-1909-turban-photo-portraits-and-historical-timeline-recap.txt — "George Walker organized the Williams & Walker Glee Club in the summer of 1905"
- c. 1905 (probable)Passage says George Walker organized the Williams & Walker Glee Club at the close of the season in the summer of 1905.
George Walker organized the Williams & Walker Glee Club in summer 1905, with Modeste Guillaume (later Abdullah) as its premier baritone among fifteen members.
Adjudication: These describe two different events -- the Glee Club's founding (summer 1905) and a later newspaper photograph of the club (1906) -- not competing accounts of one event; the group looks mis-joined. Row 0 (founding) is kept as the anchor since it is the earlier documented milestone; row 1 remains a valid separate fact rather than a rejected rival.
Person: Abdullah
Ruling: accepted (all claims kept), Rudi 2026-07-23