Date (happened)
- c. 1846 (possible)the-abdullah-investigation-the-hidden-teacher-of-neville-goddard-part-3-mokomba-mahalla-the-names-that-vanish.txt — "Neville described Abdullah as 'in his late eighties' when they met in 1929-1931"
- c. 1848 (doubtful)neville-goddard-abdullah-part-2.txt — ""which would place his birth year at 1848""
Persons
Based on Neville's descriptions of Abdullah as in his late eighties when they met (1929-1931), researchers estimate his birth year at roughly 1845-1848.
Adjudication: Both rows are researcher-derived estimates from the same underlying Neville quote ('in his late eighties' when they met in 1929-1931), not independent evidence, so neither can be called certain. Row 0's wider circa-1846 estimate (~1845-1848) better reflects the genuine imprecision of 'late eighties' than row 1's single-year 1848 calculation, which overstates precision the source doesn't support. Genuinely an estimate, not a settled fact - flagging for human judgment on which approximation to carry forward.
Person: Abdullah
Ruling: accepted (all claims kept), Rudi 2026-07-23