Date (happened)
- c. 1928 (doubtful)the-music-of-the-law-how-abdullah-encoded-neville-goddards-teaching-in-nine-lost-songs-of-1935.txt — "newspaper ad from 1928 finally placed our...spiritualist-metaphysician at...30 West 72nd Street"
- 1 November 1928historical-photographs-of-dr-modeste-abdallah-guillaume-abdullah-neville-goddards-teacher.txt — "will give a series of lectures on the...of the Soul from Nov. 1 to 8, inclusive, 8 P. M. 30 West 72d St."
- 1931 (doubtful)about-abdullah-neville-goddard-research-new-york.txt — "Hartmann's 1931 International Directory of Psychic Science and Spiritualism...quite a few classes going on in that same building"
Told / reported
- 1 December 2025 (probable)the-music-of-the-law-how-abdullah-encoded-neville-goddards-teaching-in-nine-lost-songs-of-1935.txt
- 3 November 1928 (probable)historical-photographs-of-dr-modeste-abdallah-guillaume-abdullah-neville-goddards-teacher.txt
A New York Times display ad announced G. M. Akhmad Abdoullah's lecture series 'The [Journey] of the Soul' running November 1 to 8 at 30 West 72nd Street.
Adjudication: Row 1 is a primary-source NYT display ad giving the exact Nov 1-8, 1928 lecture series at 30 West 72nd St, superseding row 0's vague reference to 'a 1928 newspaper ad' describing what is very likely the same event. Row 2 (Hartmann's 1931 directory) documents a distinct, later fact about the same address and is not truly in contest with the 1928 ad -- the group conflates a genuine same-event refinement (rows 0/1) with an unrelated later data point (row 2).
Place: 30 West 72nd Street, New York City
Person: Abdullah
Ruling: accepted (all claims kept), Rudi 2026-07-23