John 19:11, and about twenty lectures carry it. Pilate asks where are you from, and Jesus gives no answer; Pilate then says, do you not know that I have the power to set you free and power to crucify? And the reply is not a defence but a correction: you would have no power over me unless it had been given to you from above, therefore he who delivered me to you has the greater sin. Neville reads the silence and the answer as two different acts. He does not answer the first question because Pilate would never understand it, and he corrects Pilate's misunderstanding of power, which Neville calls the world's misunderstanding of power. The consequence he draws is severe and he does not soften it: the man who is used as the instrument of an act has less guilt than the one who put him to it, and since the giving is from above, the responsibility runs all the way up. At 1798, four days after the pageantry of a state funeral, he applies it to the men being blamed on the radio - if now he sends you to perform an act that is condemned by society, the one who sent you has the greater sin, for it is part of the great play. The word translated from above is anothin (M788), the same word as in you must be born from above.
Kind
Formula
Interpretive layers
Biblical typology
Psychological interpretation
Collections
Lectures
Bible wordings
John 19:11 | You would have no power over me unless it had been given to you from above; therefore he who delivered me to you has the greater sin
Occurrences
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
594353
LectureWhere Are You From
He doesn’t answer him because Pilate would never understand; and he corrects Pilate’s misunderstanding - which is the world’s misunderstanding - of power.
Span from: 138
to: 292
Passage revision:
607905
LectureWhere Are You From
And Jesus answered him: “You would have no power over me unless it had been given to you from above; therefore he who delivered me to you has the greater sin.”
Span from: 1107
to: 1266
Passage revision:
607904
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
613833
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
716955