Kind
Formula
Interpretive layers
Teaching pattern
Psychological interpretation

The hermeneutic claim that the Bible records no historical persons or events: the ancient story-tellers wrote allegorical picture-lessons of psychological principles clothed in the garb of history, and readers have mistaken personifications for persons and allegory for history. Its form is to its substance as a grain of corn to the life-germ within it. This early, flat denial of historicity is tracked here so later reframings of the question can be set beside it.

Collections
Lectures
Other quotations
St. Augustine | That which is now called the Christian religion existed among the ancients
Own wordings
the Bible has no reference at all to any persons who ever existed or to any event that ever occurred upon earth
The ancient story tellers were not writing history but an allegorical picture lesson of certain basic principles which they clothed in the garb of history
we have mistakenly taken personifications for persons, allegory for history
The difference between the form of the Bible and its substance is as great as the difference between a grain of corn and the life germ within that grain
they are psychological dramas and not historical facts
I will waste no time in trying to convince you that the Bible is not an historical fact
This Bible of ours has nothing to do with history
These stories have no reference to any persons who lived nor to any event that ever occurred upon earth
It is not physically true but it is psychologically true
They have no reference at all to any person, who lived in time and space, or to any event that ever occurred upon earth
The authors of the Bible were not writing history, they were writing a great drama of the mind which they dressed up in the garb of history
But we have mistaken their allegory for history
Having accepted the vehicle, they do not understand what the vehicle conveys
The story of Jesus is the identical story as that of the Hindu savior, Krishna
we have mistakenly taken personification for persons, allegory for history, the vehicle that conveyed the instruction for the instruction itself, and the gross first sense for the ultimate sense intended
A spiritual and symbolical interpretation alone yields truth, whilst a literal acceptation profits nothing
The perennial value of the Bible is its symbolic value
A fact of past history has nothing in it for present day religion unless it stands forth as a symbol of a Reality behind itself
the ancient teachers were not writing history, but an allegorical picture lesson of certain basic principles, which they clothed in the garb of history
The form of the various stories of the Bible is as distinct from its substance as the form of a grain of wheat is distinct from the life germ within it
Scripture is not secular history. It is salvation history

Occurrences

Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
627860
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
589514
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
625676
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
625677
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
589709
LectureRevelation
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
625148
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
590249
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
590446
The story has nothing to do with a man riding on a little colt.
Span from: 0
to: 63
Passage revision:
590493
They have no reference at all to any person, who lived in time and space, or to any event that ever occurred upon earth.
Span from: 289
to: 409
Passage revision:
590446
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
590508
Do not ask me to give up my belief in Jesus the man, or in Moses the man, or in Peter the man.
Span from: 24
to: 118
Passage revision:
590516
The Bible has no reference at all to any person who ever existed, or any event that ever occurred upon earth.
Span from: 324
to: 433
Passage revision:
590508
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
590592
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
590610
But if you have listened attentively to my message these past four nights, I do not think you want any more proof that the Bible is not history.
Span from: 91
to: 235
Passage revision:
590610
The authors of the Bible were not writing history, they were writing a great drama of the mind which they dressed up in the garb of history
Span from: 196
to: 335
Passage revision:
590592
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
590687
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
590688
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
590689
The perennial value of the Bible is its symbolic value.
Span from: 0
to: 55
Passage revision:
590685
Throughout the centuries we have mistakenly taken personification for persons, allegory for history, the vehicle that conveyed the instruction for the instruction itself, and the gross first sense for the ultimate sense intended.
Span from: 0
to: 229
Passage revision:
590687
The form of the various stories of the Bible is as distinct from its substance as the form of a grain of wheat is distinct from the life germ within it.
Span from: 0
to: 152
Passage revision:
590689
Its object is not to give an historical account of physical life, but to exhibit the spiritual possibilities of humanity
Span from: 268
to: 388
Passage revision:
590684
the ancient teachers were not writing history, but an allegorical picture lesson of certain basic principles, which they clothed in the garb of history
Span from: 279
to: 430
Passage revision:
590688
The stories conceal an underlying meaning, and the task of scripture interpretation is to discover these psychological truths which are expressed in this symbolism.
Span from: 322
to: 486
Passage revision:
590686
A spiritual and symbolical interpretation alone yields truth, whilst a literal acceptation profits nothing.
Span from: 429
to: 536
Passage revision:
590682
Scripture is not secular history. It is salvation history.
Span from: 0
to: 58
Passage revision:
590765
Learn to extract the meaning of the story, and hope it unfolds within you.
Span from: 134
to: 208
Passage revision:
590797
But when man knows the Bible is the greatest collection of psychological truths and was never intended to be seen as history or cosmology, then he gets a glimpse into this great wonderful book.
Span from: 142
to: 335
Passage revision:
590845
they are all revelations of the mind of God expressed in symbolism
Span from: 386
to: 452
Passage revision:
590896
for, as you know, it is not a book of history
Span from: 396
to: 441
Passage revision:
621612
You put your hand on the book of truth and swear to tell the truth, and here is this statement in this very book on which you swear, and you don’t believe it.
Span from: 590
to: 748
Passage revision:
625649
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
625651
A parable is a story told to illustrate a truth.
Span from: 28
to: 76
Passage revision:
591251
Now you take that, and that is the code - but what does it really mean? That it took place, actually?
Span from: 296
to: 397
Passage revision:
625783
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
591290
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
591289
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
627918
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
591659
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
591704
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
591925
Scripture was a closed book until it was acted out, the acted parable. Then we could go back into scripture and understand it. We didn’t understand it before.
Span from: 573
to: 731
Passage revision:
592057
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
592145
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
592146
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
592150
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
592158
You think that an individual, 2000 years ago, went through an agonising frightful experience to save the world. No. The story is all about you.
Span from: 0
to: 143
Passage revision:
592217
the Bible, which is the greatest book in the world, is completely misunderstood, for it is not history; it is a series of visions, which are acts of Grace.
Span from: 22
to: 177
Passage revision:
625870
The Gospel does not tell how Christ came at all, but how he comes.
Span from: 76
to: 142
Passage revision:
592243
I know the story is truer than I ever knew it to be (the story of the birth of Christ Jesus), but it is not something that took place; but it is taking place.
Span from: 0
to: 158
Passage revision:
592262
The Bible is the most modern book in the world. Every year, books come out and the concepts change as more books come out, and change and change, but here is this everlasting vision that is true.
Span from: 0
to: 195
Passage revision:
592270
Many books of the Bible are commentaries . . they are not visions, but the first five books are true visions.
Span from: 0
to: 109
Passage revision:
592272
The book called the Bible is not what any of the priesthoods of the world think it to be.
Span from: 373
to: 462
Passage revision:
592255
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
592314
Most of the eastern world says the Christian Bible is the opium of the people, and the western world says it is history. But it is a series of visions that will come only after the way is prepared.
Span from: 125
to: 322
Passage revision:
592314
It is a series of visions from beginning to end. The Old Testament shows what is taking place in the whole; the New Testament tells what is taking place in the single or individual man.
Span from: 852
to: 1037
Passage revision:
592297
the Bible is addressed to the Imagination, not to the man of sense or the man of reason – the one that is “lost” or “dead” or “sound asleep.”
Span from: 201
to: 342
Passage revision:
592329
It is the history of the soul of man and someday you will know it is taking place in you
Span from: 236
to: 324
Passage revision:
624834
you will find all through the 66 books of the Bible that He is always appearing to man in a dream
Span from: 3
to: 100
Passage revision:
592434
everything in the Bible is true on a higher level, but it is revealed figuratively, and man confused literal truth with metaphor
Span from: 42
to: 170
Passage revision:
592536
And the “Word” is the play from Genesis to Revelation. If you took all the Bibles and burned them, the play remains in spite of the written record.
Span from: 271
to: 418
Passage revision:
624555
These characters of the Bible are not people: they never walked the earth as people. We play all the characters, but they do not live any more than Hamlet lived.
Span from: 393
to: 554
Passage revision:
620543
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
689910
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
592579
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
592580
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
592891
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
593678
throughout the centuries man has mistakenly taken personifications for persons; and the acted parable for history; and the gross first sense for the ultimate sense intended; and the vehicle that conveyed the instruction for the instruction itself.
Span from: 385
to: 632
Passage revision:
593678
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
593853
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
593862
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
594250
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
594254
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
594659
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
594661
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
595036
LectureAdvent
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
595325
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
595498
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
595540
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
596648
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
596697
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
596645
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
596740
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
597015
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
597065
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
621653
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
597186
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
625298
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
624867
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
597617
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
597622
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
597753
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
597969
LectureElection
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
598297
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
598470
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
598509
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
598561
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
598570
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
598905
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
599378
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
600356
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
600384
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
627228
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
600487
LectureConception
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
600604
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
600815
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
601046
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
628391
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
601617
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
601624
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
601644
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
625902
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
628772
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
689678
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
601971
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
625569
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
602389
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
602475
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
626990
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
603496
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
603508
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
626920
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
603526
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
603690
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
621436
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
603820
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
603906
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
603962
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
603966
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
689564
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
604120
LectureThe Talent
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
628493
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
627402
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
629442
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
624574
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
626894
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
605000
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
605132
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
624949
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
624951
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
605209
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
605217
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
605220
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
605229
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
605276
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
605238
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
605247
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
605384
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
625512
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
627630
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
605448
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
605538
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
97206
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
690025
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
606152
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
606122
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
628883
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
606226
LectureDreamer 2
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
606487
LectureWord 2
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
626107
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
606560
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
606668
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
606774
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
606795
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
606999
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
606948
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
688292
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
688297
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
688299
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
607078
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
688305
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
607080
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
688307
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
607094
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
607165
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
607498
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
688134
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
607496
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
607503
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
607581