Kind
Formula
Interpretive layers
Teaching pattern
Psychological interpretation

Neville's Blake-derived statement of causation, and the bridge between two things the catalogue already holds separately. Every so-called natural effect in this world has an imaginal cause and not a natural one; a natural cause only seems - it is a delusion of our fading memory. The argument is one sentence long: our memory is so very short that we cannot connect the imaginal act to the effect we later observe, and so we deny parenthood. We cannot recognise our own harvest; we deny that we ever planted the thing we are reaping. So the natural antecedent, being the only thing still in view when the harvest arrives, is mistaken for the cause.

This stands between M259 no-other-cause (there is no cause outside your own consciousness) and M647 forgetting-how-it-was-done (the man who rises and says it would have happened anyway): it is the formula that explains WHY the secondary cause looks real, namely that forgetting is what manufactures the appearance of natural causation.

PROVENANCE: coined out of chronological sequence at the request of the attacher lane (PM 5966), which measured the formula recurring verbatim in at least 15 lectures (1204, 1216, 1474, 1530, 1783, 1831, 1861, 1939, 1971, 1972, 2148 among them) with no motif stating it. The reader's chronological read has not yet reached any of those lectures - the earliest, 1831, is about a hundred lectures ahead - so this description is written from the canonical passage alone and not from the surrounding lecture. It should be revisited and enriched when the read reaches lecture 1216 or 1831.

Collections
Lectures
Own wordings
every so-called natural effect in this world has an imaginal cause and not a natural
A natural cause only seems; it is a delusion of our fading memory
We can’t recognize our own harvest
we can’t connect the imaginal act to the effect that we observe and we deny parenthood

Occurrences

Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
620740
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
625727
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
627790
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
591459
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
591931
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
624557
He comes and shows man that causation is mental, that it is not physical – and now man has no excuse for his sin, missing the mark.
Span from: 131
to: 262
Passage revision:
625975
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
594269
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
594718
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
594729
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
594916
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
595811
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
595824
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
596126
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
596140
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
596142
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
596473
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
596607
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
596625
So every so-called natural effect in this world has an imaginal cause and not a natural. A natural cause only seems; it is a delusion of our fading memory.
Span from: 269
to: 424
Passage revision:
596581
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
597968
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
598386
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
626083
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
599059
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
601639
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
624177
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
603310
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
603522
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
603695
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
603696
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
603936
LectureThe Talent
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
604702
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
604880
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
604901
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
605109
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
605110
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
606114
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
607033
LectureOn the Law
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
607323
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
607388
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
607399
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
608516
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
609143
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
609154
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
609185
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
609186
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
627454
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
609175
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
609176
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
609182
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
609326
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
609339
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
610241
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
610348
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
688075
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
610377
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
610550
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
611014
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
611537
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
611855
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
612455
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
612547
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
612594
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
612669
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
612688
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
613631
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
613651
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
613661
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
621796
LectureInvisible
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
613927
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
628931
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
616173
LectureAndrew
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
616333
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
623360
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
617254
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
623312
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
617421
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
617537
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
618079
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
619336
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
619745
Span from: -1
to: -1
Passage revision:
620133